Keloid vs Hypertrophic Scars: Differences, Treatment and Prevention
Keloids and hypertrophic scars are both raised scars caused by excess collagen during healing. A hypertrophic scar stays within the original wound and often flattens over time, while a keloid spreads beyond the wound edges and rarely settles alone. Treatment includes silicone, doctor-given steroid injections, laser and, in selected cases, surgery.
Below we explain how to tell the two apart, why some people are more prone to them, which treatments are commonly used and what you can do to reduce the risk of a raised scar forming.
What is the difference between a keloid and a hypertrophic scar?
Every wound heals by laying down collagen. In most people this process switches off once the wound is closed. In raised scars, the body keeps producing collagen for longer than it should, leaving a firm, thickened scar.
Hypertrophic scar: raised, red or dark, and sometimes itchy, but it stays within the boundary of the original cut, burn or incision. It usually appears within weeks of the injury and often improves gradually over one to two years.
Keloid: grows beyond the edges of the original wound, sometimes much larger than the injury that caused it. It can appear months after healing, may keep enlarging slowly and seldom regresses without treatment. Keloids can be itchy, tender or painful.
Common sites for keloids include the earlobes (after piercing), chest, shoulders, upper back and jawline. Hypertrophic scars are common after burns, surgical wounds under tension and deep acne.
Why is darker skin more prone to keloids?
Keloids are seen more often in people with brown and black skin, including many people of South Asian heritage. The exact reason is not fully understood, but genetics clearly plays a role, and keloids often run in families. They are also more common between puberty and around 30 years of age.
Other factors that increase risk include wounds under tension (such as the chest or shoulder), infection or delayed healing, and inflammatory acne. Someone who has had one keloid is more likely to form another, which matters when planning piercings, tattoos or elective surgery.
What treatments are used for keloids and hypertrophic scars?
There is no single perfect treatment, and keloids in particular can be stubborn. Doctors usually combine approaches and plan for several sessions.
Silicone gel or sheets: worn daily over a period of months, silicone keeps the scar hydrated and can help flatten and soften raised scars. It is one of the most common first steps and is also used after surgery for prevention.
Pressure therapy: specially fitted garments or pressure earrings are sometimes used after burns or earlobe keloid removal.
Steroid injections: injecting a corticosteroid directly into the scar can reduce thickness, itching and discomfort. These injections must only be given by a doctor, usually spaced several weeks apart. Steroid creams should never be self-prescribed for scars.
Laser treatment: certain lasers can reduce redness, improve texture and help flatten scars, often combined with injections. Settings must be chosen carefully for Indian skin to avoid pigmentation changes.
Cryotherapy: freezing can help some smaller keloids, though it can lighten the skin, so it needs careful consideration on darker skin tones.
Surgical removal: cutting a keloid out alone carries a high chance of it returning, sometimes larger. When surgery is used, it is usually combined with injections, silicone or pressure afterwards to reduce recurrence. Hypertrophic scars that have not improved may be suitable for scar revision.
Our scar removal page outlines the scar treatments offered at the clinic, and surgical scar revision is covered under plastic surgery. For pitted rather than raised scars from acne, see acne scar treatment.
Which combination suits you depends on the scar's age, size, location and colour, your skin type and how you have scarred in the past. A small, recent hypertrophic scar on the arm may respond to silicone alone, while a long-standing chest keloid usually needs a staged plan over several months. Photographs taken at each visit help you and your doctor judge progress objectively, because changes in a scar are gradual and easy to underestimate day to day.
Can keloids be removed permanently?
Honest answer: keloids can usually be made flatter, softer and less noticeable, but there is always some chance of recurrence. Treatment is often a long-term process involving several sessions and a follow-up plan. Hypertrophic scars generally respond better and are less likely to come back once improved. Anyone who promises a guaranteed permanent cure for keloids is overstating what is currently possible.
How can you prevent a raised scar from forming?
Prevention matters most for people who already know they scar easily.
Tell your doctor: before any surgery, piercing or cosmetic procedure, mention any previous keloids. It may change the plan or lead to preventive treatment.
Care for wounds well: keep wounds clean, avoid infection and do not pick scabs.
Start silicone early: once a surgical wound has closed, silicone gel or sheets are often advised for several months.
Treat acne promptly: controlling inflamed acne, especially on the chest and back, reduces the risk of acne keloids.
Protect from sun: sunscreen helps reduce darkening of new scars.
Think twice about elective piercings or tattoos: if you have had keloids before, discuss the risk first.
When should you see a specialist?
See a doctor if a scar is growing beyond the original wound, is painful or very itchy, keeps getting larger months after healing, or is affecting your confidence. A doctor should also check any rapidly growing lump, because not every raised skin lesion is a scar. Early treatment of a new keloid is usually easier than treating one that has been growing for years.
Scar treatment in Gurgaon
Raised scars on brown skin need careful planning. At Delight Clinic in Gurgaon, Dr. Ashit Gupta, a plastic surgeon trained at CMC Ludhiana, assesses each scar and builds a plan that may combine several treatments. Patients across Delhi NCR can book a consultation at DLF Phase IV (+91-9990411335) or Sector 15 (+91-9818455159).
This article is for general information and isn't a substitute for a consultation. Suitability and results vary from person to person.
Key Takeaways
- Hypertrophic scars stay within the original wound and often improve, while keloids spread beyond it and rarely regress alone.
- Brown and black skin, family history and wounds under tension all increase the risk of keloids.
- Treatment usually combines silicone, doctor-given steroid injections, laser and sometimes surgery.
- Keloids can be improved significantly, but recurrence is always possible, so long-term follow-up matters.
- If you have had a keloid before, tell your doctor before any surgery, piercing or procedure.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know if my scar is a keloid?
A keloid extends beyond the edges of the original wound, often feels firm and rubbery, and may continue growing months after the wound healed. A raised scar that stays within the wound line is more likely hypertrophic. Only an examination can confirm it, and a doctor will also rule out other skin growths that can look similar.
Do keloids go away on their own?
Keloids rarely disappear without treatment, and some slowly enlarge over time. Hypertrophic scars, by contrast, often flatten and fade gradually over one to two years. If you have a scar that is growing, itchy or painful, it is better to have it assessed early, because smaller and newer keloids are generally easier to treat.
Are steroid injections for keloids safe?
When given by a qualified doctor in appropriate doses, steroid injections are a widely used treatment for keloids and hypertrophic scars. Possible side effects include thinning or lightening of the skin around the scar and visible small blood vessels. The doctor will space sessions carefully and monitor your response, adjusting the plan as needed.
Can I get a keloid removed surgically?
Surgery is possible, but removing a keloid on its own has a high chance of recurrence. Surgeons usually combine excision with follow-up treatments such as steroid injections, silicone or pressure therapy to reduce that risk. Whether surgery is suitable depends on the size, location and history of the keloid, which is assessed in consultation.
How long does keloid treatment take?
Keloid treatment usually takes several months and multiple sessions, with injections or laser often spaced a few weeks apart and silicone used daily in between. Some people need maintenance or occasional top-up treatment afterwards. Your doctor will set realistic goals, such as flattening and softening the scar and relieving itch, rather than promising complete removal.
Can earlobe keloids from piercing be treated?
Yes. Earlobe keloids are one of the most common types and are often treated with a combination of surgical removal, steroid injections and pressure earrings afterwards. Because recurrence is possible, follow-up is important. Anyone who has had an earlobe keloid should discuss the risk with a doctor before getting another piercing.
More articles · Book a consultation